Life

Losing Pat Cummins as Captain – it’s just not cricket. 

This is a reflection on the sandpaper rumpus in Australian cricket and people coming out against what Pat Cummins and what he said in his marathon media conference.

For clarity, this is published on Thursday 19 November 2026, the day after Cameron Bancroft’s four-thousand-word statement was released and six days after Pat Cummins’ 80-minute news conference.

Recollections, context and understanding change over time. The  sandpaper issue happened eight years ago when Pat Cummins was 24, who had played, I think, 11 tests at the time. In cricket maturity, he was very green. Eight years on, he still hasn’t reached full cricket maturity, although his EQ is more than most for his age.

When I was 24, I was Bureau Chief at Parliament House Canberra for the Australian Radio Network (1989-90) at the height of the Hawke/Keating government. Two years later, I was the PR Manager for Sydney’s bid to host the Olympic Games (1992–1993). In both jobs, I was professionally young and quite green. Nonetheless, I did both jobs to the best of my ability and highly regarded by many for my efforts. Indeed, both set me up for the next 30 plus years of work. 

I was naive to much of what was happening around me at the time. I covered or worked with some of the best politicians, political operatives, PR people, lobbyists, business people, and sundry movers and shakers of their era. They all deployed their dark arts with aplomb. They were the best in the business and successful. I was naive to their ways and means at the time. I look back now and go, ‘wow, whatever it takes, hey’. 

Maybe Cummins was oblivious to things at the time and just didn’t see it, as was the case with me in my profession. Looking back now, I see and recognise what I saw. In my case, there was nothing nefarious or illegal, it was just a way of doing things. Some things I witnessed, today, wouldn’t pass the ‘pub-test’.

Gideon Haigh in the Cricket Et Al Podcast last Friday, posed the question, could both Uzman Khawaja and Pat Cummins be telling the truth. I’m pretty sure his answer was yes. I can appreciate how two things can be true at the same time.

I’m not so sure there is a yes or no or a right or wrong in this issue. I’m hearing a lot of conjecture at present. I think we’ve all lost sight of what the question is or the problem needing to be solved. Everyone is allowed to have their own recollections and opinions

Australia can’t afford to lose another captain. Steve Smith went over the sandpaper issue in 2018. In 2021, Tim Paine went for sexting. To lose Pat  Cummins in 2026 for recalling his memories to solve un undefined problem would be wrong. It’s just not cricket.


19 November 2026